Category: Jazzocrat’s Myth Busting
These essays examine the gap between what the saxophone industry claims and what acoustics research actually supports. Each piece applies evidence-based analysis to marketing narratives, pseudoscientific product claims, and persistent folklore about tone, materials, and equipment. The goal is not skepticism for its own sake but clarity: helping players make informed decisions grounded in physics and perception science rather than wishful thinking.
-
Ishimori Wood Stone makes exceptional saxophones and the finest accessory bling in the business. But their acoustic claims don’t survive scrutiny. A documented case study.
-
In a previous trial documented on this site, my colleague and I compared five clarinet ligatures under blinded conditions and found that four were indistinguishable by sound or feel. The fifth, the Ishimori Kodama II, stood out consistently enough that I advanced a hypothesis about its wooden reed plate as a proprioceptive mechanism. This follow-up…
-
Three weeks ago, I documented a pattern. SYOS was running sponsored social media advertisements featuring black and white images of legendary saxophonists to promote their products. The players in those ads were Michael Brecker and David Sanborn. Neither endorsed SYOS. Neither played SYOS. Sanborn spent the better part of his career on a Dukoff 8…
-
A ten second diagnostic tells you whether your reed is sealing against the mouthpiece table. The objections do not survive scrutiny. The resistance is more often psychological than acoustic.
-
A blinded two session clarinet ligature trial comparing five designs found no detectable tonal differences between four conventional ligatures, while one structurally unusual design, the Ishimori Kodama II, produced a consistent and reproducible proprioceptive sensation. This post documents the methodology, results, and a discussion of what the Kodama’s wooden reed plate may reveal about mechanical…
-
Saxophone advertisements using the likenesses of legendary players to promote mouthpieces those players never publicly played raise a serious ethical question the saxophone community should examine.
-
A saxophone ligature has one job: to secure the reed. This essay explains the mechanical role of the ligature as plainly as possible and addresses why so much confusion persists around what is, at its core, a very simple device.
-
A saxophonist does not play a ligature. This essay examines the mechanical boundary conditions the ligature creates, why perceived differences between designs are real but indirect, and why tonal language misleads.
-
Vandoren has maintained deep, sustained relationships with woodwind artists for decades. This essay examines what that presence means for the saxophone and clarinet communities and how it shapes professional trust.
-
The BetterSax Burnin Ligature promotional video uses craft imagery to imply a level of handmade authenticity its manufacturing does not fully support. This essay examines the gap between the narrative and the reality.