Essays

Essays

  • Ishimori: The Finest Bling in the Saxophone World
    Ishimori Wood Stone makes exceptional saxophones and the finest accessory bling in the business. But their acoustic claims don’t survive scrutiny. A documented case study.
  • Clarinet Ligatures Revisited: A More Rigorous Trial, A Cleaner Result
    In a previous trial documented on this site, my colleague and I compared five clarinet ligatures under blinded conditions and found that four were indistinguishable by sound or feel. The fifth, the Ishimori Kodama II, stood out consistently enough that I advanced a hypothesis about its wooden reed plate as a proprioceptive mechanism. This follow-up trial, conducted with greater… Read more: Clarinet Ligatures Revisited: A More Rigorous Trial, A Cleaner Result
  • THE PROMISE DELIVERED: Inside the Partnership That Rebuilt a Legend
    By Benjamin Allen and Ellie Allen The first note didn’t surprise me. It startled me. It was a low subtone, the kind you test almost without thinking, a reflex, a way of asking a new mouthpiece who it thinks it is. But this one answered before I finished the question. The sound bloomed immediately, warm and dense, the way… Read more: THE PROMISE DELIVERED: Inside the Partnership That Rebuilt a Legend
  • SYOS, Extraordinary Science, and Unresolved Questions
    The announcement of a titanium mouthpiece from SYOS has captured the attention of many within the saxophone community. That response is understandable. SYOS occupies a position unlike any other company in the mouthpiece market, and a move into laser metal fusion titanium represents a meaningful departure from everything that defined them at their founding. It is an occasion worth… Read more: SYOS, Extraordinary Science, and Unresolved Questions
  • SYOS Is Still Using Dead Legends to Sell Mouthpieces
    Three weeks ago, I documented a pattern. SYOS was running sponsored social media advertisements featuring black and white images of legendary saxophonists to promote their products. The players in those ads were Michael Brecker and David Sanborn. Neither endorsed SYOS. Neither played SYOS. Sanborn spent the better part of his career on a Dukoff 8 Metalite. The full analysis… Read more: SYOS Is Still Using Dead Legends to Sell Mouthpieces
  • The Pop Test Is Not Optional
    A ten second diagnostic tells you whether your reed is sealing against the mouthpiece table. The objections do not survive scrutiny. The resistance is more often psychological than acoustic.
  • Clarinet Ligature Trial: What We Found
    A blinded two session clarinet ligature trial comparing five designs found no detectable tonal differences between four conventional ligatures, while one structurally unusual design, the Ishimori Kodama II, produced a consistent and reproducible proprioceptive sensation. This post documents the methodology, results, and a discussion of what the Kodama’s wooden reed plate may reveal about mechanical feedback in the reed system.
  • The Boston Sax Shop and the Vision of Jack Tyler: Why Focused Identity Creates Lasting Success
    The Boston Sax Shop has become one of the most influential boutique saxophone brands in the world. This essay examines the vision and discipline of its founder, Jack Tyler.
  • When Marketing Rewrites History: The Problem With Using Legendary Players to Sell Mouthpieces
    Saxophone advertisements using the likenesses of legendary players to promote mouthpieces those players never publicly played raise a serious ethical question the saxophone community should examine.
  • The Primacy of Response: Rethinking the Saxophonist in the Acoustic System
    The saxophone produces sound through an interactive system that includes the player. This essay examines why response, not tone, is the primary variable a saxophonist controls, and what acoustic research reveals about that relationship.
  • Authorship and Precision: The Design Philosophy of Mark Sepinuck
    Mark Sepinuck of 10MFAN rejected the saxophone mouthpiece market’s dependence on vintage geometry and built an original line of CNC-precision designs. This essay examines his philosophy of authorship.
  • Are Higher Baffle Saxophone Mouthpieces Really Louder?
    Higher baffle saxophone mouthpieces feel louder because they shift spectral energy into the frequencies the ear is most sensitive to, not because they increase total acoustic output. Players choosing these mouthpieces for projection and presence are making acoustically rational decisions. Here is what the perceptual science shows.
  • J&H Winds: When the Instrument Stops Resisting
    J and H Winds in Cedar Falls, Iowa is a boutique woodwind repair shop founded by Simon Harding and Jimmy Jensen. This essay examines their philosophy of correction, restraint, and precision.
  • One Last Essay on Saxophone Ligatures (I Hope)
    A saxophone ligature has one job: to secure the reed. This essay explains the mechanical role of the ligature as plainly as possible and addresses why so much confusion persists around what is, at its core, a very simple device.
  • You Don’t Play a Ligature
    A saxophonist does not play a ligature. This essay examines the mechanical boundary conditions the ligature creates, why perceived differences between designs are real but indirect, and why tonal language misleads.
  • Vandoren, Artist Loyalty, and its Singular Woodwind Focus
    Vandoren has maintained deep, sustained relationships with woodwind artists for decades. This essay examines what that presence means for the saxophone and clarinet communities and how it shapes professional trust.
  • Prevarication by Proximity: How Craft Imagery Shapes the BetterSax Ligature Narrative
    The BetterSax Burnin Ligature promotional video uses craft imagery to imply a level of handmade authenticity its manufacturing does not fully support. This essay examines the gap between the narrative and the reality.
  • Brad Behn Reed Case Review: A Technical Assessment of Humidity Control for Cane Reeds
    The Brad Behn Reed Case is a deliberately engineered system designed to create a stable, controlled micro-environment for cane reeds. This review examines its humidity control design and what it means for reed longevity.
  • D’Addario Woodwinds, Artist Relations, and the Cost of Absence
    D’Addario Woodwinds occupies a complicated position in the saxophone world. This essay examines what the company’s shifting public identity and reduced artist engagement have cost the woodwind community.
  • Kessler & Sons Music: Setting the Gold Standard in Musical Instrument Retail
    Buying from Dave at Kessler and Sons Music means professionally set-up instruments, exceptional customer service, and a curated inventory you can trust. Here is why it matters.
  • The Hidden Architecture of Saxophone Sound
    The terms saxophonists use to describe mouthpieces, free blowing, resistant, spread, focused, reflect real physical sensations rooted in geometry. This essay examines the architectural principles behind them.
  • Innovation Meets Legacy: Inside the New Theo Wanne and JJ Babbitt Partnership
    Theo Wanne and JJ Babbitt have formed a shared-ownership manufacturing partnership to produce Meyer and Otto Link mouthpieces with CNC precision for the first time in the history of these legendary designs.
  • Trust, Transparency, and the Modern Saxophone Market
    As saxophone manufacturing has become increasingly global, professional trust now rests more heavily on transparency and engineering discipline than on heritage and origin stories. This essay examines how different approaches shape credibility.
  • The Ligature Question: Mechanical Function vs. Psychophysical Perception
    This essay critically examines the acoustic claims made for saxophone ligatures, separating mechanical function from psychophysical perception and evaluating what controlled research actually supports.
  • A Classic Case of Confirmation Bias
    Saxophone players are uniquely susceptible to confirmation bias in equipment decisions. This essay is a personal account of gear chasing and what it reveals about how musicians evaluate their equipment.
  • Material Differences and Machining Realities
    This two part essay examines the gap between a saxophone mouthpiece’s acoustic performance and the player’s physical experience, comparing two identical geometries made from different materials.
  • The Klangbogen Divide
    This paper critically analyzes ReedGeek’s claims for the Klangbogen device, examining whether its purported effects on saxophone bore stability and sound quality hold up under acoustical scrutiny.
  • The Saxophone Industry’s Pseudoscience Problem: A Call for Critical Thinking
    The saxophone industry markets accessories with scientific sounding language that does not withstand scrutiny. This essay calls for evidence based evaluation and critical thinking in equipment decisions.
  • Confirmation Bias and the Cult of Saxophone Equipment
    Saxophone players are not irrational. They are susceptible to the same cognitive patterns that affect all human beings when desire, identity, and money intersect. This essay examines the psychological mechanism behind gear acquisition syndrome and what awareness actually changes.
  • Selmer (Paris) Premium Jazz Tenor Saxophone Reeds
    Selmer Paris Premium Jazz tenor saxophone reeds deliver exceptional uniformity, tonal complexity, and immediate response out of the box. This review compares them against five previously ranked competitors.
  • The Saxophone Tone Myth
    Many saxophonists are chasing a myth. The ideal tone they pursue is an abstraction, and the gear they buy in pursuit of it is sufficient but never necessary. This essay examines why.
  • A Cane Reed’s Moisture Line
    The moisture saturation line on a well played cane reed offers a clinical observation about mouthpiece intake. This essay examines how measuring it with a glass gauge may improve mouthpiece fitting and reed pairing.
  • Optimal Cane Reed Maintenance
    Reeds do not mature. They degrade. This essay examines the wood science, acoustics, and microbiology behind reed degradation and offers evidence based guidance on storage, rotation, and hygiene.
  • Theo Wanne Essentials Collection Jazz Mouthpiece
    The Theo Wanne Essentials collection offers high-quality saxophone mouthpieces at a more affordable price point compared to their premium Signature series.
  • Outstanding Saxophone Repair Shop in Boston, MA
    The Boston Sax Shop is a specialty saxophone shop and repair destination in the Allston neighborhood of Boston, MA. This is an account of an emergency repair and the exceptional care that followed.
  • Boston Sax Shop Ambassador II
    The Boston Sax Shop Ambassador II is the finest saxophone case currently available. This review examines its design, construction, and value against the Bam Cabine and Walt Johnson cases.
  • Boston Sax Shop Cloud Strap
    The Boston Sax Shop Cloud Strap is the most comfortable saxophone strap I have ever worn. This review compares it against the Marmaduke Feather IV, Whimory Balam, Breathtaking Lithe II, and Jazzlab Saxholder.
  • Selmer (Paris) Serie III Soprano versus Yamaha Custom Soprano
    An extended comparison of the Selmer Paris Serie III and Yamaha YSS-875EX soprano saxophones, examining tonal character, build quality, and ergonomics from the perspective of a player who has spent considerable time with both.